When God’s faithfulness seems to contradict our circumstances, how do we remain close? A personal reflection on Psalm 89: praise, lament, disappointment, and learning to come to our Father with unanswered questions.

Lately, I feel like I have forgotten how to pray. My heart literally feels broken, like shards of glass from a broken vessel. So I go to the only place I know to process through my pain and find the words that my heart can’t seem to find on its own.
This morning God directed me to Psalm 89, and I wept.
Not because I discovered something new about God’s faithfulness, but because I recognized the ache of my own heart in its words.
These past few years, I have found myself living in what feels like a contradiction. I know God’s nature. I know His goodness, His mercy, His faithfulness. I have walked with Him for years. I have experienced His kindness, heard His voice, and built my life around what I believe to be true about Him.
And yet, when I look at some of the circumstances of my life, I struggle to reconcile what I see with the God I know.
I find myself praying, Lord, I know You. But this doesn’t seem to be in line with who I know You to be. Help me understand. Help me live with the contradiction without becoming offended. Keep Your nature before my heart, even when my eyes see something different.
And then I opened Psalm 89.
I Will Sing of Your Faithfulness
The psalm begins with a beautiful declaration:
“I will sing of the mercies of the LORD for ever: with my mouth will I make known Your faithfulness to all generations.” — Psalm 89:1
For the first eighteen verses, the writer, Ethan the Ezrahite, celebrates God’s character.
He remembers His steadfast love, His righteousness, His justice, His power, and His faithfulness.
Then he recounts God’s covenant with David, remembering the promises God made to establish his throne and preserve his descendants.
God had declared:
“My covenant will I not break, nor alter the word that has gone out of my lips.” — Psalm 89:34
What a beautiful assurance.
But then something happens.
But You, Lord…
Verse 38 begins with a startling change:
“But You have cast off and abhorred, You have been furious with Your anointed.”
Suddenly, the same writer who has spent thirty-seven verses praising God’s faithfulness begins describing circumstances that appear to contradict everything he has just celebrated.
The crown has been cast to the ground. The walls have been broken down. Enemies are rejoicing. The king has been humiliated.
And the psalmist isn’t simply describing what has happened.
He is bringing his disappointment directly to God.
You made these promises. You established this covenant. You declared Your faithfulness. But look at what has happened.
I recognize that cry.
There are seasons when I can look back and remember the things I believed God spoke, the ways I followed Him, the decisions made in faith, and the years spent trusting His leading.
And then I look around at what life has become.
Some things have unfolded very differently from what I expected. Some hopes have remained unfulfilled for so long that I hardly know what to do with them anymore.
And I find myself asking, Lord, how do I reconcile this?
Not because I have stopped believing in His goodness, but precisely because I believe in it.
Perhaps that is what makes the disappointment so painful.
The contradiction hurts because we know the One whose faithfulness we are struggling to see.
Where Is the Love You Promised?
As the psalm continues, the writer asks:
” How long, LORD? Will You hide Yourself forever?” — Psalm 89:46
And then:
“Lord, where are Your former lovingkindnesses, which You swore to David in Your truth?” — Psalm 89:49
Where is the love You promised?
I read those words and wept.
Because sometimes that is the most honest prayer I have.
Not a polished prayer. Not a prayer that carefully explains away my disappointment before bringing it to God.
Just a daughter asking her Father, Where are You in all of this?
I know what Scripture says about Your goodness. I know what I have experienced of Your love. I know what I have believed You were leading us into.
But I don’t understand what I am seeing.
And I need You to help me.
When Praise and Lament Live Together
Something fascinating happens at the end of Psalm 89.
Actually, something doesn’t happen.
The writer never resolves the contradiction.
He doesn’t receive an explanation. He doesn’t suddenly understand why the circumstances seem so opposed to God’s promises.
His lament ends with the weight of his unanswered questions still hanging in the air.
But the final verse reads:
“Blessed be the LORD for evermore. Amen, and Amen.” — Psalm 89:52
This verse is widely understood to be the closing doxology of Book III of the Psalms, rather than the original conclusion of Ethan’s prayer.
In other words, the lament itself likely ends without resolution at verse 51.
I find that incredibly comforting.
The people who preserved these psalms didn’t feel the need to clean up the writer’s disappointment. They didn’t remove his questions or insist that he finish by explaining why everything was actually wonderful.
They allowed his grief to remain.
And they placed it within the worship of God’s people.
What if praise and lament were never meant to cancel each other out?
What if lament is not the opposite of faith, but one of the ways faith continues to reach toward God when life no longer makes sense?
I can praise God for His faithfulness and still grieve what I do not understand.
I can remember His goodness and still ask where that goodness is in my present circumstances.
I can love Him deeply and still feel disappointed.
And perhaps I can bring all of that to Him without first making it acceptable.
Coming Close With My Disappointment
I think what frightens me most is not the disappointment itself, but the possibility of allowing it to change how I see God.
I miss Him.
I miss the closeness, the ease of conversation, the joy of simply being with Him without feeling the weight of everything I cannot understand.
And I don’t want to lose that.
For so long, I think I have felt the need to understand my disappointment before bringing it to Him. To examine my heart, reconcile the contradictions, find the right perspective, and somehow arrive at a place where I can come without all these unanswered questions.
But perhaps that is exactly what He is inviting me to stop doing.
What if I don’t have to fix my disappointment before I come?
What if I can come confused, grieving, even struggling to trust what I cannot see?
What if the invitation isn’t to understand Him better before drawing near, but to draw near so that I can be with Him in the things I don’t understand?
That is what I am beginning to see in Psalm 89.
The psalmist doesn’t resolve the contradiction between God’s promises and his circumstances. He brings it to God.
And perhaps that is what I am learning to do.
I don’t want to become offended. I don’t want disappointment to harden into a judgment against God’s character. But I am beginning to see that protecting my heart from offense doesn’t mean protecting God from my honest feelings.
He can receive my disappointment.
I don’t have to clean it up first.
Learning to Remain
Jesus says in John 15, “Abide in me.”
Not understand everything about Me.
Not figure out what I am doing before you come close.
Just abide.
Remain.
And perhaps remaining isn’t always a peaceful confidence that everything will work out. Sometimes remaining looks like reaching toward the One you love through tears, saying, I don’t understand what You’re doing. I am deeply hurt. But I don’t want to go anywhere else. I want to be close to You.
I am beginning to recognize the difference between trying to maintain my faith in God and allowing myself to be His daughter.
One feels like a responsibility I must carry. The other allows me to come to my Father with the very feelings I have been trying to resolve.
I don’t know how every part of my story will unfold. I don’t know how the things I have hoped for, prayed for, and believed will be reconciled with the life I am actually living.
But perhaps reconciliation isn’t the prerequisite for intimacy.
Perhaps intimacy is where I can bring what I cannot reconcile.
And so my prayer is changing.
Father, I know Your nature. I know Your heart. But there are things I cannot understand, and I am afraid of allowing my disappointment to overshadow what I know to be true about You.
I miss You. I don’t want to stand at a distance trying to make sense of everything before I come near.
Teach me to bring my disappointment to You instead of trying to fix it first.
Keep Your nature before my heart, even when my eyes cannot see it.
And when I cannot reconcile the contradiction, help me remain.
Because more than I need an explanation, I want to be close to You.
I don’t have to understand my disappointment before I bring it to my Father.
I can bring it to Him because He is my Father.

In everything you do -eat, play, and love- may it always be seasoned with Joy!
This post contains affiliate links, which means I make a small commission at no extra cost to you. Unless stated otherwise, I will only recommend products I personally enJOY. See my full disclosure here.
