Can we receive what God gives us through suffering without believing He gave us the suffering itself?

I’ve been thinking lately about what a gift it is to have people to walk with on this journey of faith. People who aren’t afraid to ask hard questions, share their experiences, and wrestle through what they believe about God.
We were never meant to walk alone.
There is something beautiful about bringing our different experiences to the table, opening Scripture together, and allowing what we know of God’s character to challenge what we think we understand.
It’s not about proving who is right or wrong. It’s about pursuing truth together.
Sometimes our experiences seem to confirm what we believe about God. Other times, they appear to contradict everything we thought we knew. And rather than quietly drawing our own conclusions, we have the opportunity to bring those contradictions into the light with people who love Him as much as we do.
Recently, I’ve been having conversations with two dear friends who have been battling chronic illness. Both love Jesus deeply. Both have endured years of suffering and unanswered prayers. Yet their experiences have led them to consider suffering from different perspectives.
And their willingness to share their hearts has invited me to examine my own.
One friend has found tremendous freedom in beginning to see her suffering as a gift from God. After years in an environment where healing seemed dependent on having enough faith, she is discovering the relief of no longer feeling responsible for making her healing happen.
Another friend has been wrestling with the distinction between the sufferings of Christ and the sickness and affliction we experience in a broken world.
Meanwhile, my husband and I have been navigating our own long season of financial hardship, waiting, and unanswered questions.
Different experiences. Different perspectives. The same desire to know God as He truly is.
And somewhere in these conversations, a question has emerged:
When God brings something beautiful out of something devastating, does that mean the devastation itself was His gift?
When the Revelation Is the Gift
Years ago, I sat in a church service listening to a man share his testimony.
He described how he had been a workaholic, spending so much time making money that he was missing the very family he was working to provide for.
Then he developed Parkinson’s disease.
His illness forced him to slow down. He began recognizing what truly mattered: his family, his relationships, and the beauty of being present.
He called Parkinson’s the greatest gift God had ever given him.
He even shared that when people offered to pray for his healing, he declined. He didn’t want to lose the gift that had transformed his life.
I remember sitting there deeply troubled.
Not because I questioned the beautiful revelation he had received. I believed him.
But I wondered, What if Parkinson’s wasn’t the gift?
What if the gift was the revelation?
What if God had taken something devastating and brought something beautiful out of it?
Would that make the devastation itself good?
I don’t believe it would.
And that distinction has stayed with me.
What Does Jesus Reveal About the Father?
When I want to understand God’s nature, I look at Jesus.
In John 14:9 (NKJV), Jesus tells Philip that whoever has seen Him has seen the Father.
So when I want to understand how God feels about sickness, I look at how Jesus responded to the sick.
He healed them.
He touched lepers, opened blind eyes, restored broken bodies, and delivered those who were oppressed.
Acts 10:38 (NKJV) describes Jesus going about doing good and healing those oppressed by the devil.
I don’t see Jesus telling the sick that their disease was a precious gift they needed to embrace.
I see Him moved with compassion.
That doesn’t answer every question about why healing sometimes doesn’t come. Scripture itself leaves us with examples of faithful believers who continued to experience affliction.
But Jesus’ ministry tells me something important about the Father’s heart.
James 1:17 (NKJV) reminds us that every good and perfect gift comes from above.
And I want to be careful not to automatically label something a gift simply because God has brought something good out of it.
What Are the Sufferings of Christ?
Scripture certainly doesn’t promise us a life without suffering.
Jesus tells His disciples in John 16:33 (NKJV) that they will experience tribulation in this world, but He also calls them to courage because He has overcome the world.
Paul speaks of knowing Christ through the fellowship of His sufferings in Philippians 3:10.
And in Philippians 1:29, Paul describes suffering for Christ as something granted to believers.
But I’ve been looking more carefully at what those sufferings involved.
Much of what Jesus and the apostles endured came through their obedience to the Father and the opposition that followed. They experienced persecution, rejection, imprisonment, and hardship because they followed Him.
That doesn’t mean Christians cannot experience illness, poverty, grief, or loss. Romans 8:17–23 describes a creation groaning under corruption, waiting for redemption.
We live in a world that has not yet been fully restored.
And while suffering for Christ is not limited to persecution alone, I think we need to be careful about treating every form of suffering as something God personally selected for us.
There is a difference between suffering because we follow Christ and suffering because we live in a broken world.
And there is a difference between God sustaining us through suffering and God being the author of everything that causes us pain.
The Part of Job We Sometimes Forget
Job is often brought into conversations about suffering.
We remember his losses, his grief, his questions, and eventually his extraordinary encounter with God.
Near the end of the book, Job declares in Job 42:5 (NKJV) that he had previously heard of God, but now his eyes had seen Him.
What a beautiful testimony.
But there is something important about Job’s story that I think we sometimes overlook.
Job didn’t know what the reader knows.
In Job 1:6–12 and 2:1–7, we are given a glimpse into a heavenly conversation.
The adversary comes before God and challenges Job’s integrity. He questions whether Job loves God for who He is or merely for the blessings he has received.
And then, within limits God permits, the adversary attacks Job’s life.
Job loses his possessions, his children, and eventually his health.
But Job doesn’t know about the conversation in heaven.
He doesn’t know the adversary has challenged his faithfulness. He doesn’t know what has been permitted or why.
He is trying to understand his suffering with only part of the picture.
And isn’t that so much like us?
We experience loss, sickness, disappointment, and circumstances that seem impossible to reconcile with God’s goodness.
And we try to explain what we cannot see.
Job famously declares in Job 1:21 that the Lord gave and the Lord took away.
Scripture tells us Job did not sin in his response. Yet the opening chapters have already shown us that the adversary was the immediate instigator of his suffering, operating within limits God permitted.
That doesn’t resolve every question about God’s sovereignty. The text itself presents a mystery about divine permission and the enemy’s activity.
But it does challenge the assumption that because God permits something, He must delight in it or intend it as a gift.
Job’s story gives us a glimpse behind the curtain.
We rarely have that privilege in our own lives.
And perhaps that should make us a little more humble about the conclusions we draw from what we experience.
When We Are Too Tired to Keep Fighting
One of my friends recently shared something that touched me deeply.
After years of chronic illness, unanswered questions, and countless attempts to find relief, she was exhausted.
She had spent so much time trying to understand why this was happening and what she needed to do to make it stop.
And then something shifted.
She began considering whether perhaps God had chosen this path for her. Maybe the suffering itself was the means by which He was transforming her. Maybe she could stop fighting to escape it and simply trust Him.
And for the first time in a long time, she felt a weight lift.
I understand that relief more than she may realize.
For seventeen years, my husband and I have been walking through a journey of faith that has looked very different from what we believed God had spoken over our lives.
We’ve experienced financial hardship, loss, disappointment, and seasons when provision seemed painfully out of reach.
I’ve wondered whether we misunderstood something, whether we made mistakes, and whether the promises we believed we received would ever come to pass.
And I’ve had to confront some of the ways my charismatic background shaped my expectations.
I no longer want a faith that depends on performing correctly, declaring the right words, or somehow producing an outcome through my own spiritual effort.
That is exhausting.
But neither do I want to resolve the tension by deciding that poverty is God’s gift to my family.
I cannot call the inability to meet our needs good simply because I have discovered a deeper dependence on God through it.
Dependence is good.
Intimacy with Him is good.
Learning to receive daily bread is good.
But I don’t believe lack itself is the gift.
And this is where my friend’s experience has caused me to consider something.
What if the freedom she has discovered is real, but the conclusion she has attached to it isn’t necessarily the whole picture?
What if God is inviting us to stop striving without asking us to call our suffering His gift?
What if we can surrender our attempts to control the outcome without surrendering our hope that He desires something better?
Was the Suffering Necessary?
This is a question my husband and I have been wrestling with alongside a dear friend.
We can look back over these seventeen years and recognize extraordinary intimacy with God.
We’ve learned dependence, humility, perseverance, and a deeper understanding of His love.
But was all of that suffering necessary to produce this intimacy?
I don’t know.
James 1:2–4 (NKJV) tells us to count it all joy when we encounter various trials, knowing that the testing of our faith produces patience and maturity.
But I don’t believe James is asking us to call evil good.
He is inviting us to recognize what God can produce in us through difficulty.
Romans 8:28 (NKJV) promises that God works all things together for good for those who love Him.
It doesn’t say that all things are good.
And Joseph’s story offers another beautiful distinction.
After years of betrayal, slavery, imprisonment, and separation from his family, Joseph tells his brothers in Genesis 50:20 that although they intended evil against him, God intended it for good, to preserve many lives.
Joseph did not have to call his brothers’ betrayal righteous in order to acknowledge God’s redemptive purpose.
We can recognize what God has accomplished through suffering without claiming to know what He could have accomplished without it.
And perhaps that is where humility begins.
There Is a Third Way
I think sometimes we find ourselves caught between two explanations.
One says that if we had enough faith, we would be healed, provided for, and delivered from our circumstances.
The other says that because we haven’t been healed or delivered, God must have chosen these circumstances for us, and our task is to embrace them as His gift.
But what if neither explanation is necessary?
What if we can stop striving without surrendering hope?
What if we can rest in God’s goodness without deciding that everything we suffer is an expression of His goodness?
What if we can say:
This sickness is not good, but God is good.
This poverty is not good, but God is faithful.
This loss is not good, but God can meet me here.
I do not understand why this continues, but I will not allow my circumstances to become the final authority on who He is.
That is not denying reality.
It is acknowledging that reality is bigger than what I can presently see.
And it is learning to distinguish between God’s sovereignty and His approval.
The fact that God can redeem something does not necessarily mean He delights in it.
The fact that He permits something does not automatically mean He asks us to celebrate it.
And the fact that we haven’t yet experienced healing or provision does not mean we have failed to believe correctly.
We can continue to ask for healing without striving to produce it.
We can trust God for provision without calling poverty a blessing.
And we can receive His comfort without believing that suffering is the price we must pay for intimacy with Him.
Holding On to What Is True
Something God has been teaching me lately is that I don’t have to resolve every contradiction before I come to Him.
For so long, I have tried to understand my circumstances, explain my disappointment, and make sense of what has happened before bringing my heart to the Father.
But perhaps faith looks less like having the correct explanation and more like bringing Him my unanswered questions.
Psalm 89 has become especially precious to me because the psalmist does exactly that.
In Psalm 89:1–2 (NKJV), he begins by celebrating God’s mercy and faithfulness.
But by verses 38–49, his words have become a lament over circumstances that seem to contradict God’s covenant promises.
He doesn’t pretend the contradiction isn’t there.
He brings it to God.
And that is where I find myself.
I don’t want to let seventeen years of disappointment rewrite what I believe about God’s character.
But I also don’t want to pretend those years haven’t been painful.
I want to remain honest about both.
I believe God is a healer, even while I see people I love still waiting for healing.
I believe He is a provider, even while my own family continues to experience financial hardship.
I believe He is faithful, even when I cannot see how His promises will unfold.
And I believe He can bring extraordinary beauty out of suffering without requiring me to call the suffering itself beautiful.
Perhaps that is the distinction I am learning to hold.
The suffering may not be the gift. But the Father who meets us in it is.
I can receive Him without calling everything that has happened to me good.
I can rest without resigning myself to despair.
I can keep asking without striving.
And I can keep hoping without pretending I understand.
And I’m grateful that God has given me people who are willing to walk alongside me as we wrestle through these things together.
Because we were never meant to figure it all out alone.
We were meant to seek Him together.

In everything you do -eat, play, and love- may it always be seasoned with Joy!
This post contains affiliate links, which means I make a small commission at no extra cost to you. Unless stated otherwise, I will only recommend products I personally enJOY. See my full disclosure here.
